3 minutes reading time (603 words)

MIT Just Cut Ties with Nectome, the '100-Percent-Fatal' Brain-Preserving Company

Brain_MIT

Source: Live Science

MIT announced today (April 2) that it has severed a subcontract with Nectome, a company that says it will preserve the brains of dying people in order to revive them in the future.

MIT's announcement stated that it is cutting off a subcontract that involved the university in Nectome's grant-funded research through MIT neuroscientist Ed Boyden's lab. Nectome has received more than $915,000 in grant funding from the National Institute of Mental Health.

Live Science reported on the company's "100-percent-fatal" brain-preserving service in March. Neuroscientists Live Science interviewed at the time were deeply skeptical, saying that there is no reason to believe the deadly service would actually make it possible to revive a person in the future. [Top 10 Weird Ways We Deal with the Dead]

Remarkably, MIT's announcement also includes a detailed critique of Nectome's research, beginning by stating, "Neuroscience has not sufficiently advanced to the point where we know whether any brain preservation method is powerful enough to preserve all the different kinds of biomolecules related to memory and the mind. It is also not known whether it is possible to recreate a person’s consciousness."

The university also said that Boyden "has no personal affiliation — financial, operational, or contractual — with the company Nectome."

Nectome's plans sounded outlandish, but its MIT-graduate founders boasted of the involvement of high-profile MIT neuroscientist Ed Boyden. As MIT Technology Review reported in a flattering profile of the company published March 13, Nectome has already won a prize for successfully preserving the nerve network, or connectome, of a dead pig. And the company later tried out its process on the 2.5-hour-old corpse of an elderly woman. In the future, Nectome plans to preserve the brains of living people, as a means of physician-assisted suicide.

The theory behind Nectome's ultimate goal is that a well-preserved connectome, or map of all the links between a brain's nerves, might contain enough information for future scientists to digitize and use to re-create a dead person's consciousness. When Technology Review published its article, a number of tech and science publications jumped on the story, repeating the grisly, fatal service's most ambitious claims.

However, neuroscientists Live Science previously spoke to were deeply skeptical.

"The important question," Harvard neuroscientist Sam Gershman said, "is whether the connectome is sufficient for memory: Can I reconstruct all memories knowing only the connections between neurons? The answer is almost certainly no, given our knowledge about how memories are stored — itself a controversial topic."

Florida State University neuroscientist Jens Foell previously told Live Science that key information would be lost in preserving the connectome.

"It's true that synapses are where all the action happens," he said. "But cell firing behavior is determined by other things, including processes within the cells that are determined by proteins that are much smaller than synapses — and some of them are short-lived)."

A number of neuroscientists publicly criticized Nectome, as well as other researchers who had worked with them or implicitly supported them.

It's worth noting that not every neuroscientist agrees that Nectome's promises are total bunk.

Following the earlier article, Sebastian Seung, a connectome expert at Princeton University, wrote an email to Live Science offering some support for Nectome.

"I agree that the Nectome route is far-fetched," he wrote. "But I can see someone making a rational judgement that Nectome is better than the alternatives: 1) normal death with zero probability of revival and 2) Alcor with no demonstration of connectome preservation."

(Alcor is a cryonics company that freezes bodies after death.)

Seung, whose Ted Talk appears on Nectome's website, but who isn't directly involved in the company, also debated at length with Nectome's critics on Twitter.

 

How Medical Marijuana Could Help Curb the Opioid E...
Herbalife Nutrition Clubs

Related Posts

 

Comments

No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment
Already Registered? Login Here
Guest
Monday, 21 October 2019
This website is protected by RSFirewall!, the firewall solution for Joomla!

front1

AccessJamaica

Wait a minute, while we are rendering the calendar
Theo Chambers
02 April 2018
Wellness News
This is how people find support in their communities to help them achieve their goals.Herbalife Nutrition Clubs are at the heart of how Herbalife helps people change their lives and their communi...
Sharon Parris-Chambers
08 January 2017
Medical Marijuana
Wellness News
The Washington Post - By Marie Myung-Ok Lee January 6It took me awhile to perfect the cookie recipe. I experimented with ingredients: Blueberry, Strawberry, Sour Diesel, White Widow, Bu...
Sharon Parris-Chambers
06 February 2017
Wellness News
SOURCE: healthy-holistic-living.comPhoto Caption: Brazil About to Refuse ALL Imports of U.S.- Grown Genetically-Modified CropsBrazil — The list of countries refusing Monsanto’s genetica...
Sharon Parris-Chambers
22 November 2016
Allergies
Wellness News
Better go check your fridge: Sabra, one of America’s most ubiquitous brands of hummus, is recalling dozens of products due to a listeria scare. The recall includes 57 varieties, or the vast majority o...
Theo Chambers
17 February 2018
Nutrition
Wellness News
Source: The Guardian NewspaperIt was reported last week that Quorn is on course to become a billion-dollar business. It is part of a booming industry of meat alternatives – but many of these products ...
Theo Chambers
15 April 2018
Wellness News
Source: Cosmos Magazine - ANDREW MASTERSON is news editor of Cosmos.It’s all a matter of language, in the end. Take toiletries: what the manufacturers might term “personal care products”, sc...
Theo Chambers
09 March 2018
Wellness News
Source: Business InsiderStates around the country — 29 of them, plus Washington DC — have legalized medical marijuana.The American public largely supports the legalization of medical marijuana. At lea...
Theo Chambers
02 April 2018
Wellness News
With a mission to positively impact the lives of children through nutrition and education, along with Herbalife’s purpose to making the world healthier and happier, the Herbalife Family Foundation (HF...
Theo Chambers
02 January 2018
Wellness News
Source: WiredYOU ENTER THE University of Colorado Boulder's newest research laboratory through the side entrance. The door—which is heavy and white, with a black, jug-style handle—slides open fro...
Theo Chambers
03 October 2018
Wellness News
Barbecued pork or fried chicken served with a heaping side of mac and cheese or creamy potato salad, sweet tea and peach cobbler — these Southern classics, loaded with as much history as flavor, have ...
Theo Chambers
04 October 2017
Wellness News
Source: BBCThe salt content in some pesto sauces has increased despite a push to reduce levels, a campaign group has found.Consensus Action on Salt and Health said Sacla's Italia Organic Vegetarian Pe...
Theo Chambers
31 December 2017
Wellness News
WRITTEN BY: Olivia Goldhill - QZ.Com Some 2,000 years ago, the Ancient Greek scholar Hippocrates argued that all ailments, including mental illnesses such as melancholia, could be expla...
Theo Chambers
11 February 2018
Wellness News
According to Cardiogram founder Brandon Ballinger’s latest clinical study, the Apple Watch can detect diabetes in those previously diagnosed with the disease with an 85 percent accuracy.The study is p...
Theo Chambers
03 April 2018
Medical Marijuana
Wellness News
Source: Live ScienceRates of opioid prescriptions went down in states that implemented laws allowing access to medical marijuana, according to two studies published today (April 2) in t...
Theo Chambers
03 April 2018
Wellness News
Source: Live ScienceMIT announced today (April 2) that it has severed a subcontract with Nectome, a company that says it will preserve the brains of dying people in order to revive them in the future....
Theo Chambers
09 May 2018
Alternative Medicine
Wellness News
Source: FuturismEven when you’re asleep, your brain is on. It’s constantly communicating with every part of your body, sending electrical impulses and specific chemicals throughout your muscles a...
Theo Chambers
02 April 2018
Wellness News
Source: Tae Kim | @firstadopter - CNBCCiti Research raises its rating to buy from neutral for Herbalife shares, citing the company's attractive valuation versus the market.We "expect Ac...
Theo Chambers
12 April 2018
Wellness News
Source: Cosmos MagazineEven bees that never leave the hive can be exposed to insecticides and herbicides that affect their sense of taste and reduce their ability to learn.        ...
Theo Chambers
15 August 2018
Wellness News
Source - CPG InsightsIf so, good for us. (Note: opinions here vary.)But it's likely a broader trend, as US mayonnaise sales have fallen 6.7% over the past 5 years, and more natural...
Theo Chambers
07 October 2018
Wellness News
Source-Live Science - By Brandon Specktor, Senior WriterCan a task force of insects carrying genetically modified viruses save America's farms — or are they an uncontrollable bioweapon in th...
Theo Chambers
19 September 2018
Wellness News
Large hospital systems don’t command high prices just because patients like them, or just because they have strong market share. There's also another big reason: their contracts with insurance compani...
Theo Chambers
23 February 2019
Wellness News
Source: Mind Body GreenTalk to most functional medicine providers, and the majority will tell you that health begins in the gut. Well, I disagree. Health begins in the environment. Allow me to explain...
Theo Chambers
16 September 2019
Wellness News
By Theo Chambers Majority of the times your doctor will recommend that you change your diet because many of our illnesses are lifestyle-related. What is amazing and very frustrating, is that 90% of al...